Farm Animals 29

Carlton H. Plummer Sr.

November 2, 1938 ~ November 17, 2019 (age 81)

Obituary Image


On Sunday, November 17, 2019, Carlton Plummer Sr., loving husband, father, brother, grandfather, and great grandfather passed away.

Carlton was born November 2, 1938 in Medina to Howard and Marion Plummer. He and his brothers Lee and Gary, grew up in Lyndonville where Carlton’s passion for raising animals and taking care of the land was realized. His life’s work was dairy farming and served his community as the Future Farmers of America State Treasurer and as a long standing member of the Lyndonville School Board. Carlton imparted his work ethic, honesty, and his humble love of nature to his ten children. Carlton enjoyed a hot cup of coffee and peanut butter sandwich after coming in from morning milking. He loved watching his grandchildren play and holding babies on Kendrick Road. He could be found tilling the garden with his team of horses or bringing the cows in from pasture with his favorite dog Mickey. Carlton spent his free time picking out the perfect chopping block for his wife Mary, hunting, reading the newspaper, solving a crossword puzzle, or watching westerns. He was a kind, genuine, patient, and generous man who will be missed greatly by everyone he knew.

Carlton is preceded in death by his father Howard, his mother Marion, and his brother Gary.

  He is survived by his loving wife of 26 years Mary Dooley, his brother Lee (Val, Ray, Lori, Penny), his children Carlton Jr. (Roxanne, Dylan and Evan), Courtney (Lisa, Jasmine, Jocelyn), Jeffrey (Michelle, Michael, Nikki, Ryan), Todd (John, Chase), Russell (Alex and Peyton), Randall (Paige, Bailey, Shelby), Megan (William, Kendyll, Leigha), Ingrid, Martin (Jenna, Aubrey, Sylvia, Everett), and Gabriel (Jenna, Sylas, Mable, Eliza, Betty).

The family will be hosting a memorial service and celebration of his life at the Ridgeway Fire Hall at 3 P.M. on Saturday, November 23, 2019. This event is to celebrate the life of a farmer and as such the family requests that friends and family dress comfortably to honor him.

In lieu of flowers, the family requests donations to Orleans County Cooperative Extension 4-H Program, 12690 NY-31, Albion, NY 14411.

Arrangements were entrusted to the Bogan & Tuttle Funeral Home, 226 Pearl St. Medina, NY 14103. Please light a candle or share a memory of Carlton at:

To send flowers to the family or plant a tree in memory of Carlton H. Plummer Sr., please visit our floral store.


Celebration of Life
November 23, 2019

3:00 PM
Ridgeway Fire Hall
11392 Ridge Rd.
Medina, NY 14103


Orleans County Cooperative Extension 4-H Program
12690 NY-31, Albion NY 14411

© 2020 Bogan & Tuttle Funeral Home, LLC. All Rights Reserved. Funeral Home website by CFS & TA | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use